Over the past few months, I’ve contemplated one of the most complicated topics in baseball.
Travel ball.
This multi-million dollar machine has watered down local rec leagues and become the preferred source of youth baseball. This expensive, multi-layered topic that is travel ball has caused the landscape of the kid’s game to change. As a parent, travel ball gives you the feeling like if you don’t join it, you are falling behind. If you can’t pay the money, drive the hours, and stay in the hotels then your kid won’t have a future in the sport. Parents stuck with these challenges have no definitive answer on what is right or wrong. So, I wrote this to help clarify and sort through them one by one. Some questions I aim to address in the article are:
Does travel ball help develop my son or daughter better than rec ball?
Is travel ball necessary for my son or daughter to play at the next level?
Does travel ball help with exposure and recruiting?
Does travel ball increase risk of injury?
But, before I jump into the state of the game today, it’s important to talk about how youth baseball began.
History of youth baseball
To know how we got to where we are, it’s important to go back to where it all began. Some people never take the time to learn how youth baseball came about. If I gave you one guess on what year organized youth baseball began what would you say?
Way back in the late 1800’s, adult “club” teams in New York formed and sponsored pre-teen leagues to give the younger kids a place to play. The problem with this was the equipment was all stuff made for the adult club teams. This included old broken bats and beat up gloves and balls. So, a good idea with poor execution led to these youth teams fizzling out. Can you imagine going to a travel tournament where all the kids were swinging adult sized bats and hitting ripped up balls? Most parents wouldn’t make it through the first game before pulling their kids out and going home.
It wasn’t until 1888 when William Buckingham Cutis founded the AAU (which I played in when I was 12). Cutis’ youth league was different, working close with the Olympic movement to prepare athletes for the Olympic Games. Baseball wasn’t in the Olympics back then, but having rules built the foundation for the development youth baseball that it lacked.
By the 1900’s, youth baseball started to pick up again. In 1925, the American Legion formed as the first baseball program to provide a national baseball tournament for teens. But, it wasn’t until 1938 when youth baseball had its official beginning all thanks to a man named Carl Stotz. Carl, like every other dad at the baseball field, just wanted a place for his young nephew to play. So, he decided to organize a league for him and the other kids in Williamsport, Pennsylvania (the present day site of the Little League World Series).
His goal of the league was to “teach young ball players the fundamentals of sportsmanship, fair play and the concept of teamwork”. Simple and straight to the point. We can all agree that even in today’s world that goal still applies. What followed Stotz’s idea of a place for the kids to play was a cascade effect of leagues across the country. The Pony League in 1950 by the Pennsylvania YMCA as an acronym for “Protect Our Neighborhood Youth” (later named “Protect Our Nation’s Youth”). The Babe Ruth League then came in ’51 as a league for youths from ages 13-18 who had grown past the Little League age limit of 12 to play on adult sized fields. Several leagues continued to form for different reasons. Each one has a very specific goal in mind and each one with the intention of getting more kids to play the game of baseball.
The rise of travel baseball
Yet, with all these leagues in place, still somehow, there was room for more new organizations. This included the USSSA (United States Specialty Sports Association) and Perfect Game. These orgs now required traveling further distances to face better competition. This, in turn, is supposed to accelerate development to a greater degree than rec ball. This all sounds great, until the bill comes.
The price to pay to play for a travel team? It depends. Teams can range from a couple hundred dollars a “season” to a couple thousand. Yes, I said per season. A season is a batch of tournaments that the organization has committed to playing in for the upcoming few months. Each team requires you to pay for the upcoming season and then requires another payment upon the next season beginning. Business minded travel orgs can then create as many “seasons” as possible in a calendar year to maximize their profit.
But what does this money go to each season? Team fees? Hotels? Uniforms? Baseball stuff? It’s true that to enter into bigger tournaments, you have to pay bigger fees as a team. But, according to IRS filings in 2015, the USSSA generated $13.7 million and the CEO received $831,200. $831,200. So, when an organization like USSSA says to your team “pays this fee”, the coach then turns to parent and says “I need this amount of money for this fee”. If Perfect Game raises a price, it comes out of the parents pockets not the coach’s. Yet, if the coach decides to make nicer uniforms, that comes out of the parents pockets too. As a parent, it can feel like more and more every year. All for what? Guaranteed college scholarships?
The sales pitch here is that by playing in bigger tournaments you are facing better competition. By playing in front of college/professional scouting departments, you increase your exposure. But how does a parent verify if that’s even true? How can you really know that the money you are spending each year is going into further developing your kid? How can we MEASURE that? If he runs, hit, and throws like everyone else that plays rec ball what is the extra money for travel ball for? Not to mention what about all the extra pressure paying that much money as a family puts on these younger kids?
In a 2016 study, Dorsch and his colleagues found the more money families pour into youth sports, the more pressure their kids feel (1). They also enjoyed less and felt less committed to their sport. At such young ages kids are being taught to be serious because there’s money on the line now. Don’t laugh, don’t fall down, don’t strike out because we are counting on you to make good on our money we spent. Kids respond one of two ways: step up and play well or the more likely scenario “I don’t want to play this game anymore”. Gone are the days of wiffle ball in exchange for a semi-professional version for 7-14 year olds. But does it even help more than the local rec league?
Does it help more than rec ball?
Let me preface my answer first by saying I loved rec ball. I hit a home run off of one of my best friends. I threw my first no-hitter. I played on a team full of kids from my school and we won a city championship. We had local team names from businesses we all knew. My brother beat a team that named after a local bank that had the best players on it. I got to see my older brother throw one of the best games of his life. When the games were over, we ran to the concession stand for hot dogs and a coke. If my baseball career stopped after that, I would’ve always those memories. I loved baseball because of that league. My parents didn’t have to drive far and the cost was much less than travel ball. So, was that local rec ball league the reason I played college baseball? No. But would driving three hours away to a tournament every weekend been any better? Definitely not.
It’s not fair to compare my experiences with kids today. The mass exodus of talented players from local rec leagues makes it a shell of what it was for me as a kid. In the 90’s, lots of good athletes played rec ball during baseball season because we could play the other sports the rest of the year. The league was stacked with talent making every game helpful in our development. We didn’t need to go out of town to face faster pitching because it was there. Home runs were hit every game, so we never sought out tougher competition. Now, you are lucky to find more than a few kids in each league that can hit a ball over the fence. Parents turn their nose up to rec ball because it’s become the league for kids that don’t have the option to play anything else. Quality coaches are exiting the rec ball scene to either watch or coach their kids travel ball teams. This leaves rec ball scrambling to find someone to coach and hardly able to fill more than a few teams. In turn, it’s more of a mess than a game of baseball.
Unfortunately, to get quality reps off of more difficult competition, travel ball is the way to go. However, I think the way that travel ball is set up for young kids it can be more hurtful than helpful. Do you face better pitching sometimes? Yes. Do you also face the same quality as rec ball at times? Also yes. Mixed in with average competition, you also have the issue of being forced to play 5-7 games in a 2 day span. Why on earth do we think it’s a good idea for a roster of 10-12 kids to have to play 7 games in a weekend? Don’t we have a better understanding that these are not fully grown adult bodies? Most of these kids don’t even have growth plates that have closed. Yet, we think it’s a great idea to structure tournaments to dehydrate, create muscular damage, and a lack of sleep before school on Monday in an effort to get better?
Before I go further, it’s important to discuss what makes a kid “good” at a young age. Is it that they are just more skilled than others? Is it that they just work harder than others? Unfortunately, at young ages no matter how much you practice that doesn’t change the fact that Body weight (mass) is the biggest differentiator at younger ages. The more mass you have behind the swing/throw, the easier it is to have success on the small field. Now, as kids get older, differences in body weights shrink and skill level becomes the separator. This can also lead to setting kids up for failure down the road. Kids who were bigger at younger ages may not feel the need to practice as hard. The skinnier, smaller kids may have learned to work harder because they were behind and set a better foundation for when they are older. So, 8-12 year old baseball is really a strange time to push championships and winning on kids over developing skills and building a foundation that will help them move forward on the big field.
Are they ready for THIS type of baseball?
I was introduced to travel ball when I was about 12 years old after my dad and a few other parents decided to put a team together. We had a group that would enjoy playing a few more weekends per year. We practiced a few times a week and only drove a few hours away. Practices consisted of developing the group of local kids into a team. I still remember my dad saying “This is for the state championship” before he would hit the last fly ball or ground ball of the practice. Our goal was never a travel baseball trophy. We were developing into a team prepared for the big moments. In our last year of high school baseball, a majority of those kids were on our team when we won a huge playoff game. It felt like we had been practicing for that game since we were 12 on that travel ball team. Again, the goal was to develop into a team not to win a travel ball trophy.
It wasn’t until I was 16 that a team from outside of my area code reached out to my parents and asked me if I would be interested in playing for them. By that time, I had decided baseball was the sport for me and that it gave me the best opportunity to play at the next level. This team played in front of collegiate recruiters in big tournaments out of state. It was something I had never experienced until my senior year in high school. I say that because kids that haven’t even started playing on 90′ bases have already played more out of state tournaments than I did by the time I was 16. 10-year-old kids are being put into high pressure situations in a game where you fail more often than not. Are they ready for it? Are the you ready for it as a parent? Do they even have the brain function to comprehend what it means to work for something that won’t come to fruition for years?
I strongly believe that kids at younger ages are not ready for this type of competitiveness. If the environment for travel ball was encouraging and coaches helped kids through struggle, my answer would be different. Instead, it’s parents yelling at kids for getting out in a game where you get out a lot more than you don’t. It’s coaches putting kids lower in the lineup after their batting average drops. It’s yelling on the way home from games, during practice, at home because kids have to perform right now. So, no, young kids are not ready for that. A kid in high school has more personal skills to handle failures and can make his or her own decision if this is the path for them going forward. Young kids, however, are told to like a sport and be committed to playing it for a whole year. If we as coaches, parents, adults can make it more positive and encouraging during the inevitable struggles than travel ball can serve a purpose. But, if it leads to arguments among parents and a strain on families both financially and creating more stress than is the juice worth the squeeze at young ages?
Is it necessary to play at the next level?
This is a resounding no. Easy answer for me given the fact I’ve been able to see so many minor league baseball players and asked them firsthand, “Did you play travel baseball?” This question gets a lot of yes answers. But, occasionally, you get a, “No, I played football and basketball until my last year of high school when I decided to try out for varsity baseball.” If travel baseball was the only way to play college baseball how do multi-sport athletes get there?
Let’s take a closer look at football. A sport comprised of strength, speed, agility, and power. As a young football player, you learn to sprint at high speeds and change directions on a dime. You have to be strong and powerful, and you have to have the necessary footwork to stay off the ground. Amateur baseball scouts are looking for tools when they watch showcases. Sprint speed, arm speed/strength, bat speed/power, hand eye coordination (glove), and the ability to hit are all tools that will be sought out. A player that possesses even one of these elite tools can be drafted based off of the ability for the scout’s team to help cultivate the rest. Pro organizations believe in their coaching staffs. They will take their chances coaching a player that already has elite sprint speed because it’s unique. You can learn to field a ground ball, but sprinting faster than everyone else is rare.
So, going back to travel ball. If the five tools are what gets you further, how much does it help enhance those tools? Does playing in a game every weekend help your son or daughter run faster, throw faster, field better, hit further? If your son or daughter lacks the foundational strength that answer is no. A pitcher with no lower body or core strength that continues to throw 59 mph for two years isn’t being “scouted”. If you’re a Toyota Prius, driving it more won’t give it a bigger engine. Taking time in the gym instead of playing will. This is what leads to gains in throwing velocity, bat speed, and sprint speed. More weight room time, way less game time. What about defense and swing work? If that’s below average will playing more fix that? This takes individual work to increase those skills. Money spent on travel tournaments would be better served paying for a coach to teach these skills outside of competition. So, travel ball is not necessary to play at the next level as long as you are developing one or all the five tools as much as possible.
Now, what about a player with above average tools that has strength and power as well as the skill to perform? That player needs more game reps! This is where travel ball fills a need. This player has the potential to be great and is a sports car in the garage. This player should be out on the field improving their game decisions and applying what they know and possess into a competitive setting. See? Not against travel ball, but it needs to be for the right person. If your son or daughter has the horsepower of a Prius, they are not hitting the ball very far no matter how many Perfect Game tournaments they play in. But if your kid has tremendous power and needs to see more live pitching, go for it. As a parent, you need to be honest and assess the situation instead of paying the money expecting something to happen. Develop speed, agility, strength, and power first and then play in games that showcase those things.
Does it help with exposure or recruiting?
I can answer this using what was already discussed. Does your kid throw a collegiate level speed? Does your kid run at a professional level? Does he have a better swing than most kids in the county? If these answers are yes, travel baseball can help draw more attention to the tools each kid already has. If your kid is throwing 62 mph, what would the extra exposure do? College and pro scouting departments have a budget that allows for each evaluator to travel to tournaments. That scout needs to eat, sleep, and drive to places. Scouting departments need to know exactly where to go to maximize efficiency. Knowing this, do you think that scouts drive to tournaments watch every game on every field? They work off of preferred list of players that already have commitments or gained interest at some point.
If you see scouts at a game, they are there to watch specific players that already have shown the possibility of playing at the next level. If your kid happens to be around those players and runs a 3.8 to first base, you may be in luck. If your son throws 70 mph in a high school tournament, chances are that scout has already seen a thousand kids throwing 70 mph. If your travel team promises to get your son noticed but does nothing to improve his throwing velocity in two years, stop wasting money. That money could’ve gone to a gym membership and a private instructor that would’ve given you back two fold what you paid. Now, with that increased throwing velocity, you can go to a showcase and have a better chance of getting a call. It’s about developing the athlete first, then building the skills to gain attention.
So, does travel ball help with recruiting? Only if you meet the requirements that a scout is looking for. If not, spend the time working to develop those things before you go back into that realm.
Does travel ball increase risk of injury?
This, without a doubt, is a yes. More innings equals more opportunities for something to happen. Please don’t confuse that with WILL happen. More games only mean that the probability goes up. Throwing more innings gives the arm more chances to break down, so on and so forth. But don’t just take my word for it, there are a ton of studies backing this guy’s opinion. In 2011, Fleisig et al. published a study following 481 youth pitchers for a 10-year span (2). In this study, they found pitching more than a 100 innings per year significantly increases the risk of injury. In fact, pitchers that threw more than a 100 innings per year are 3.5 times more likely to be injured.
Travel baseball allows pitchers to throw more in a given calendar year. Some youth pitchers throw in their rec ball leagues as well as two or three other travel baseball teams. This causes inning counts to grow especially if you factor in bullpens and other throws made at other positions. I remember throwing 3 innings in a travel ball game and then starting in the next game 30 minutes later. In total, I threw 10 innings in a row and couldn’t straighten my arm the next day. That year started what would be a few years of arm injuries for me. I went from throwing with no pain to battling arm fatigue and pain. If mismanaged, travel baseball can add more stress to the arm and bring injury closer to fruition. But, if mapped out correctly and a plan is put into place, injury risk can be mitigated. Baseball at younger ages is about development and not winning. Before you commit the money to participate, talk with each coach about their plan for your kid’s arm. Once the season begins, make sure they adhere to it throughout the season to allow for healthy years down the road.
Is my kid getting left behind?
At the end of the day, this is the question every parent struggles with. Am I helping to set my son or daughter up for success? Everyone else seems to be doing it and I don’t want to hurt my kid’s chances. But is your kid getting left behind if you don’t play for a few years? Well first, it’s important to point out that whether you play or don’t at the youth level, around 2% of high school athletes go on to play Division I sports. Even if you play every single year on the very best team money can buy, those are the facts. Maybe it increases your likelihood of being in that 2%.
Again, I played in travel baseball since I was 12 years of age, and was fortunate enough to play college baseball. But, I also played high school golf, basketball, and football. It’s true that if you play other sports you develop more athletic qualities than those who do not. I believe long-term development should be an athlete first approach. Less playing games in a single sport and more about developing as an athlete. So, if you decide to play travel ball does your kid miss out on playing another sport? If so, you may be helping in the short term but hurting in the long term. Taking a break from baseball in no way hurts your kid in the grand scheme of things at young ages. However, taking time off of competitive sports altogether could possibly hinder future goals. You are more likely to be left behind at the high school level if you only focus on baseball versus the athletic kid who plays multiple sports and never burns out from baseball.
Younger ages benefit from more reps of every sport. If those reps are from basketball, you are getting agility, explosiveness, teamwork, playing a role within a group. If you can play catch in the backyard a few times a week during basketball season, you are golden. Plus, spending time in another sport will make that kid appreciate baseball even more when he or she comes back. If your kid is somewhere competing against good athletes, rest assured baseball is not leaving them behind. As your child gets older, it becomes more important that they begin taking more reps in a specific sport. By the age of 14, it’s time to start spending a majority of time on 1-2 sports only and placing all the eggs in those baskets.
So who is travel ball for?
Travel baseball is being packaged and sold as the optimal way to get better at the sport. Hitters see faster pitching; pitchers face better hitters. Iron sharpening iron, right? Gaining these experiences would then give motivation needed to aspire to be better. Some coaches tell parents they are going to “help develop each kid so that they have a better chance of playing at the next level”. For that, just pony up a couple thousand dollars a year and little Johnny is on the road to success.
But how can parents be sure you are receiving what you paid for? How do you measure “developing each kid to have a better chance at playing at the next level”? In any sales industry, if I tell you that a product is worth $3,000, wouldn’t you want to make sure you get what you are paying for?” At a car lot, you pay a price and you get that specific car. In a barber shop, you pay for a haircut and receive the haircut. These examples are transactional. Travel baseball, however, sells a product that takes years to come to light, if ever. So why the high fees for something that isn’t guaranteed?
I think travel baseball can be very beneficial for some athletes. The question is, is it right for YOU the specific reader. Would money spent on travel ball be better spent on private instruction? Would going on a non-sport related vacation this summer set your son or daughter back? Would spending money on a strength & conditioning coach to gain velocity be more beneficial than pitching more innings at the same velocity?
In my opinion, travel ball is set up for kids that have the physical qualities ready to play at higher levels. These are also kids with good work ethic, confidence, are coachable, and demonstrates leadership. Kids much younger need reps, strength training, and skill development. Will travel ball have some fun times? Absolutely. Will the younger kids get better because they play more? Definitely. But a couple grand on travel baseball at younger ages isn’t necessary. Good quality reps can happen in the backyard or at the local field. Playing other sports may end up being more productive for baseball than actually playing baseball at young ages. Chances are your son or daughter will become a better athlete and have more tools to show down the road. If a travel ball structure is setup to allow for 2-3 games in a weekend, I support that 100%. This would mean that pitchers wouldn’t “have” to throw multiple times and we aren’t crushing kids to the point of exhaustion. Let them get their work in and then get home/fed/recovered.
Thank you for following along during this long form article. I have thought for a long time about this topic and decided that in order to voice my opinion, I would need it to be organized. I have worked at the professional level and have now worked with young athletes for the last year. It has been an eye opener for me and I see a very complicated landscape with difficult topics. I do not believe my answers are the only, and hope that I’ve provided enough evidence to help parents sift through the noise. With this, maybe you can make a more educated decision with your money. After all, it is your money and you shouldn’t feel pressured into spending it something. In the future, I plan on answering more difficult questions such as:
“Should young kids lift weights”?
“Is it too soon to learn an offspeed pitch?”
“Should my son be hitting the ball on the ground or the air?”
“Should we work on throwing strikes before throwing hard?”
Stay tuned and share this article if it was helpful or can help someone you know.
References:
1. Ryan Dunn, C., Dorsch, T.E., King, M.Q. and Rothlisberger, K.J. (2016), The Impact of Family Financial Investment on Perceived Parent Pressure and Child Enjoyment and Commitment in Organized Youth Sport. Fam Relat, 65: 287-299. https://doi.org/10.1111/fare.12193
2. Fleisig, G. S., Andrews, J. R., Cutter, G. R., Weber, A., Loftice, J., McMichael, C., Hassell, N., & Lyman, S. (2011). Risk of Serious Injury for Young Baseball Pitchers: A 10-Year Prospective Study. The American Journal of Sports Medicine, 39(2), 253–257. https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546510384224